Picture yourself in a running store.
You’ve made time to train. You want to feel stronger, move better, and look like the work is paying off. Now you need shoes.
One pair promises more cushioning. Another has a carbon plate. Someone tells you that you need support. Someone else says less shoe is better.
You pick up the expensive pair and wonder: Is this what I need, or just what everyone is wearing?
I get asked this question a lot: “Javier, what shoes should I train in?”
Let’s walk through that decision together.
First, tell me about tomorrow
Are you going for a walk? Running easy before work? Training for a race? Lifting weights?
That answer changes what I would look for.
Your shoe protects your foot, grips the ground, and holds you securely. Its shape and stiffness also affect how you move. A springy shoe designed for running might not feel steady under a squat.
So before we look at the wall of shoes, we look at your week.
For daily walks, I want you comfortable and secure through a natural stride and turns. For running, I want you to try the shoe at the pace you actually use. For lifting, I want a stable platform. That doesn’t always mean a flat sole: an elevated lifting heel can change squat mechanics in useful ways, depending on the person and the lift. Research on lifting shoes
Now, try the impressive-looking pair
It feels soft. Almost bouncy.
That can be useful. But standing on soft foam tells us less than moving in it.
Walk. Jog. Turn. Does your heel stay put? Are your toes squeezed? Do you feel pressure under the arch? Do you feel secure, or are you working to stay balanced?
Then you notice “zero drop” on another box.
That describes the height difference between the heel and forefoot. It isn’t a promise of healthier feet. A six-month study of 553 runners found no overall injury advantage among zero-, six-, and ten-millimeter versions of a shoe. Read the study
My advice: if a shoe has been working for you, understand what you are changing and why. Don’t introduce unfamiliar shoes, a new running technique, and a harder training week all at once.
And the carbon-plated shoe?
You don’t need to dismiss it as hype.
Some advanced running shoes help you use less energy at the same pace. And you don’t necessarily have to be fast to benefit: a 2026 study found savings at slower recreational running speeds too. That was a small study of particular shoes, not a guarantee for every pair or every runner. Read the study
The question becomes: Does this help with the running I actually do?
Try it at your intended pace. Pay attention to control and comfort, then to how your feet and calves respond afterward. An impressive specification doesn’t settle that decision for you.
Before you buy, look at the pair you brought in
How long have you used it? How much running, walking, and everyday wear has it had?
Don’t judge only by whether the sole has a hole. Check traction, heel hold, tears, and uneven compression. In one small study, runners didn’t reliably feel measured cushioning changes as their shoes accumulated mileage. Read the study
The familiar 300–500 running-mile guideline is a useful reminder to reassess, not an expiration date. Persistent pain or swelling needs attention beyond a shoe purchase.
Now you can leave the store with a reason for your choice.
You know what the shoe is for. You’ve tried it doing that job. And you know what to watch as you use it.
Take these three steps before your next purchase:
Write down your main activity and usual pace.
Bring your current shoes and the socks you train in.
Compare how the candidates feel while moving, not just standing.
The same thinking belongs in your training. Start with what you want to achieve, understand where you are now, and choose the next step for a reason.
Want to train on your own with a clear plan to follow? Explore the Endurance Cartel training programs and choose the one that fits your goal.
Coming next: What does your foot need from a shoe?
Flat feet, high arches, pronation, a stiff big toe: which details matter when choosing a shoe, and which ones don’t tell the whole story? We’ll look at how your foot moves, where you feel pressure and when extra support may be worth trying.
Javier Pineda
OWNER, Endurance Cartel
Get the next Training Insight
Enjoyed this article? Join Javier’s weekly newsletter for more practical training ideas. Reading the articles is free and does not require subscribing.
